After months of debate, Aurora City Council on Monday pulled the plug on a proposed gas station, liquor store and restaurant at East Alameda Avenue and Powhaton Road, siding with neighbors who loudly objected. The 4-3 vote stops the All In One Harmony project in its tracks and leaves the future of the prominent corner wide open for now.
Council vote, recusals and split
Council denied the conditional-use permit on a 4-3 vote, reversing an earlier planning commission approval and going against city staff recommendations, according to Sentinel Colorado. Councilmembers Stephanie Hancock, Gianina Horton and Angela Lawson voted to approve the permit, while Mayor Pro Tem Alison Coombs and councilmembers Alli Jackson and Ruben Medina voted to deny it.
Mayor Mike Coffman and Councilmember Amy Wiles recused themselves from the case, and Councilmembers Françoise Bergan and Curtis Gardner were absent, adding another layer of drama to an already tight vote.
Neighbors’ concerns and petition
Harmony residents lined up to tell council the project would mean more traffic, more noise and worse air quality, and they argued the proposed hours clashed with neighborhood quiet times. A petition against the plan drew more than 800 signatures, a show of force that clearly landed with several councilmembers.
“I don’t see that the particular gas station and liquor store is going to help that community at all,” Councilmember Ruben Medina said as he explained his no vote. According to Sentinel Colorado, residents have been pushing back on the proposal since it was filed in September 2025.
Developer changes and planning history
Developer Manraj Singh tried to calm the waters as the project moved through review, trimming an original plan for 24-hour operations down to shorter hours and pitching a “good neighbor” agreement that promised a designated point of contact and regular site maintenance…