You don’t have to travel to the East Coast to experience New England vibes. There are some places in the Midwest that have the historic buildings, scenic landscapes, and cozy delights that many associate with towns in Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the rest. One such location is Sunbury, Ohio, a small, fast-growing city with lots of historic charm. Founded in 1816, Sunbury’s downtown is home to several 19th-century buildings and a traditional town square inspired by those found in New England. Today, the walkable historic district features local eateries and shops with a friendly atmosphere — think “Gilmore Girls,” but in Ohio.
After spending much of its history as a sleepy village, Sunbury has seen rapid growth over the past few decades thanks to its proximity to Columbus — about a 40-minute drive away — and its location along the growing employment corridor of I-71. It’s also less than a two-hour drive from both Dayton and Akron. As its population grew, Sunbury transitioned from a village to a city in 2021, and the growth shows no signs of stopping: its population increased 37.54% from 2020 to 2025 (according to World Population Review), making it one of the fastest-growing cities in Ohio.
Sunbury’s historic downtown could pass for New England
You’d be forgiven for thinking Sunbury’s historic district is in New England. The traditional Sunbury Square is bordered by a three-story town hall and courthouse built in 1868, and the brick building could easily fit into many classic New England towns. Elsewhere, the Myers Inn Museum was first a home, then a stagecoach inn, and now it is an educational center and local landmark, with a barn next door featuring a blacksmith’s shop and stable. Outside, you’ll see a bronze statue of General William Stark Rosecrans riding a horse, a monument to a Civil War general rather than a Revolutionary War one, a reminder that despite the New England vibes, Sunbury’s history is very rooted in Ohio’s past.
Bordering the square, you’ll find a quaint antique shop and local restaurants. Shoppers can spend hours treasure-hunting in Weidner’s Village Square Antique Mall, where Google reviewers praise the variety of items, affordable prices, and hidden gems. Some also point out that there’s a mix of “junk” and real treasures — which of course, is part of the appeal for others. And if you’re on the vintage trail in this part of the country, don’t miss the best Midwest destinations to shop for antiques…