Step inside and take a breath—the air itself at Wittich’s Candy Shop seems to shimmer with sugar. It’s the kind of place that sparks childhood nostalgia even if you’ve never been, where the glass cases gleam with jewel-toned candies and the soft clink of a vintage soda fountain echoes in the background. In a world of polished, corporate sweet shops, Wittich’s stands out like a rare gem, proudly calling Circleville, Ohio, home since 1840, making it the oldest family-owned candy shop in America.
Whether you’re a lover of chocolate-dipped everything, hand-pulled taffy, or simply a fan of history you can taste, Wittich’s is a delightful step back in time. You’ll feel as though you’ve walked into a delicious pocket of the past—but with just enough modern charm to keep you lingering longer than you planned.
What We Love
Handmade Chocolates That Melt Just Right
The chocolates here are crafted the old-fashioned way, and you can taste the difference immediately. Rich, smooth, and perfectly portioned, each bite feels like it was made just for you.
The Old-Time Soda Fountain
Grab a seat on a classic spinning stool and order a phosphate or an ice cream soda just like your grandparents might have. Watching the staff mix and pour your treat adds to the experience.
Candy Case Eye Candy
Rows upon rows of colorful treats line the cases: butter creams, fudge squares, and glistening hard candies that catch the light and make choosing almost impossible—but that’s part of the fun.
Personalized Service With a Smile
There’s something heartwarming about being greeted by name—or simply by warm friendliness—by staff who truly love this place. You’re not just another customer here; you’re part of their sweet tradition.
Atmosphere & Setting
Wittich’s feels frozen in a charming time warp. From the dark wood counters to the antique candy molds displayed on the walls, every detail honors the shop’s storied past. The mood is gentle and welcoming, filled with soft chatter and occasional bursts of laughter. A faint vanilla-sugar aroma lingers in the air, wrapping visitors in a cozy embrace as they browse. Natural light pours through old storefront windows, illuminating the rows of penny candy and gleaming soda glasses, while the clatter of scoops and tongs provides a soothing soundtrack.
Value (Is It Worth It?)
Absolutely—and then some. Prices are reasonable for handmade confections, with most goodies costing just a few dollars apiece. Expect to spend 30 minutes to an hour here, depending on how lost you get in browsing and sampling. It’s a perfect stop for families seeking a fun outing, couples on a nostalgic date, or anyone passing through Circleville who appreciates a taste of tradition. Bonus: it’s a great spot to pick up one-of-a-kind gifts for friends and family.
Other Considerations
Parking is available along West High Street and nearby side streets, usually without much trouble. The shop is open most days, but it’s smart to check their hours before you go—especially if you’re planning a weekend visit. The historic building is accessible, though space can feel tight when the shop is busy. No need to rush; this is the kind of place where you’re encouraged to take your time. If you’re visiting Circleville during the famous Pumpkin Show in October, plan for big crowds and lots of festival atmosphere—Wittich’s becomes even more magical then!
A visit to Wittich’s Candy Shop isn’t just about satisfying your sweet tooth—it’s about savoring a slice of small-town history, wrapped in caramel and dipped in chocolate. Whether you’re reliving childhood memories or making new ones, this Circleville treasure is well worth the detour.
Wittich’s Candy Shop
📍 117 W High St, Circleville, OH 43113