PA man with sinkhole coverage has claim rejected after lawn caves in: ‘The yard just kind of disappeared in front of me’

Bradley Stepp was outside his Coplay, Pennsylvania, home on Oct. 25 when, as he puts it, “the yard just kind of disappeared in front of [him].” Water then rushed in through the opening, and the family’s basement ended up with “four inches of water” across the floor, he told WFMZ.

Stepp thought he was covered. He had sinkhole coverage through Grange Insurance, but after he filed a claim, the company told him the hole didn’t fit its definition of a “naturally occurring limestone deposit,” WFMZ reported. Stepp argues a broken water main, not nature, caused the collapse.

Must Read

Moneywise contacted Grange Insurance for its take and was told: “To protect the privacy of our policyholders, we do not publicly discuss the specifics of any claim.”

Why a sinkhole policy may not pay

The dispute hinges on wording. Standard homeowners policies typically don’t cover sinkhole or other earth movement damage, according to Progressive, and sinkhole coverage added by endorsement depends on the terms of the policy itself.

That definition can make a big difference. Pennsylvania’s Department of Conservation and Natural Resources says sinkholes form naturally in the state’s limestone and dolostone landscape, but human activities can accelerate them…

Story continues

TRENDING NOW

LATEST LOCAL NEWS