A legal battle between two Eagle residents and their homeowners’ association over its rules banning businesses from the neighborhood continues with a new counterclaim over the neighborhood’s clubhouse.
At the end of 2023, the Two Rivers Subdivision HOA filed a complaint with Ada County’s Fourth District Court against Yuriy Buchinskiy and his wife, Valentina Buchinskiy, aiming to force them to stop operating their small businesses out of their home in the upscale subdivision. The HOA says they violate the CC&Rs that block any businesses from operating in Two Rivers to keep the area specifically for residents and their visitors, not business traffic.
This sparked an ongoing lawsuit between the couple and the HOA over whether the subdivision’s rules are being arbitrarily enforced against them specifically for complaints about traffic to and from Valentina Buchinskiy’s clothing alteration business in her home. In their defense against the suit, the Buchinskiys pointed to more than 100 businesses registered in the subdivision, including one LLC registered to Two Rivers HOA Board President Kevin Zasio and six registered to Eagle City Council Member Craig Kvamme and his wife, who also serves on the HOA board. They argue that these registered businesses, no matter if they are only mailing addresses or other homes being used for meeting with customers, show the HOA is not forcing compliance with the subdivision’s rules evenly…