Florida’s dining scene has faced a succession of closures in recent months, with local mainstays and big-name chains alike shutting down unexpectedly. In Jacksonville, four Arby’s locations vanished; St. Augustine’s King’s Head Pub called it quits; and Ocean One Bar and Grille shuttered its six Florida restaurants with minimal explanation. Now, the well-regarded Barley & Pie Brewing Company joins this unfortunate list, announcing it will end operations on April 5, 2025.
A Local Favorite in Fleming Island
Barley & Pie was more than just a place to grab a meal. It held the distinction of being Fleming Island’s first craft brewery and North Florida’s first sourdough neo-Neapolitan pizzeria. Best known for its creative take on comfort food—ribs, burgers, and, of course, sourdough pizza—the eatery also gained a loyal following for its welcoming atmosphere, dog-friendly outdoor seating, and regular live music.…