Hometown Desserts, nestled at 507 Pine Avenue in Anna Maria, Florida, is a charming bakery and dessert shop beloved by locals and visitors alike. Serving from Monday to Friday, 10 AM to 4 PM, and on Saturday until 5 PM, this sweet destination brings smiles with custom cakes, pies, cheesecakes, cookies, brownies, cupcakes and more.
At the heart of their offerings are stunning custom cakes, available in sizes ranging from intimate 6‑inch cakes (around $30) to three‑layer 9‑inch beauties (~$60). Flavors include classic choices like vanilla cream, red velvet, key lime, strawberry, chocolate decadence, and coconut cake, along with indulgent premium options such as carrot cake with walnut cream cheese frosting, chocolate mousse cake, raspberry truffle, and sour cream pound cake in multiple flavor twists hometowndesserts.com.
Pies are another highlight. Signature creations include key lime pie, peanut butter pie, bourbon chocolate pecan, apple pie, berry pie, and seasonal varieties like pumpkin pie or pumpkin pie cake, typically priced around $25–$30 per whole pie. Their cheesecakes—available in 9- or 10-inch versions—come in flavors like Key Lime, Turtle, Cookies & Cream, Red Velvet, Cappuccino Mocha, Peanut Butter Cup, and more (~$60 for the 10-inch). hometowndesserts.com. For those with dietary restrictions, they offer gluten‑free options such as flourless chocolate cake and key lime pie (~$45–$30)
Beyond cakes and pies, Hometown Desserts serves up cookies, brownies, scones, quiche, and mini to standard cupcakes, with customizable fillings, frostings and toppings—think coconut, toffee bits or fresh fruit. Many products are offered in trays and assortments, perfect for events or gift giving…