Three nursing homes in the Buffalo area paid a combined $9 million to resolve government fraud claims tied to how they billed Medicaid and Medicare, New York Attorney General Letitia James announced on August 17, 2026. The facilities named in the case are Safire Rehabilitation of Northtowns, Safire Rehabilitation of Southtowns, and Williamsville Suburban Nursing Home. Unlike many fraud settlements that close without any finding of fault, the three homes admitted wrongdoing as part of the resolution. For residents and families who depend on Medicaid or Medicare to pay for nursing home care, the case is also a reminder that the data a facility reports to the government can shape more than its own bottom line.
A $6 Million Medicaid Settlement Split Between Albany and Washington
The larger of the two settlements resolves allegations that the Safire homes submitted false data to inflate the reimbursement rates New York’s Medicaid program paid them. Under the terms of the settlement, the three facilities paid $6 million on the Medicaid portion of the case — $3.6 million going directly to New York State and the remaining $2.4 million paid to the federal government, which covers a share of every state Medicaid program’s cost. That split is standard for Medicaid fraud recoveries because Medicaid is funded jointly by state and federal taxpayers; when a nursing home is found to have overbilled the program, both funding sources are repaid in the same settlement, in proportion to what each contributed. Because nursing home Medicaid spending draws on that shared pool of public money, overbilling by a handful of providers ultimately competes with the dollars that fund care for other residents statewide.
The Safire homes also admitted wrongdoing as part of the deal, according to the attorney general’s office — a detail that sets this case apart from the more common settlement in which a company pays money while denying liability. “Nursing homes that commit financial fraud are stealing funds meant to provide care for our most vulnerable,” Attorney General James said in announcing the resolution.
A Separate $3 Million Medicare Resolution, Same Conduct
On top of the Medicaid settlement, the Safire homes paid an additional $3 million to the federal government to resolve separate allegations that the same billing practices defrauded Medicare, the federal insurance program most Americans rely on after age 65. Combined, the two resolutions bring the total repayment to $9 million under a settlement agreement covering both programs. Medicaid and Medicare are billed differently even inside the same nursing home: Medicaid typically covers long-term stays for residents who have exhausted their savings, while Medicare usually pays for a limited window of rehabilitative care following a hospital stay. Because the underlying conduct touched both kinds of billing, the case produced two separate payments to two different government payers rather than a single combined figure.
How a Twice-a-Year Rate Calculation Was Gamed
New York’s Department of Health sets a nursing home’s Medicaid reimbursement rate using data the facility itself reports about how much rehabilitative care its residents need, and that data determines the rate paid on claims for roughly the following six months. A joint investigation by the attorney general’s Medicaid Fraud Control Unit and the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of New York found that, from July 2016 through December 2020, the Safire homes exploited that calendar: during the assessment windows that fed the rate-setting formula, the homes inflated how much rehabilitation certain residents needed, then reduced the rehabilitation those same residents actually received once the assessment period had passed and no longer affected the rate.
U.S. Attorney for the Western District of New York Michael DiGiacomo said the settlement “reinforces our commitment to safeguarding federal funds and ensuring seniors receive the care they deserve.” The audit behind the case was led by Auditor-Investigator Rebecca Whitescarver under the supervision of Regional Chief Auditor Mary Henry, with the settlement itself handled by Special Assistant Attorneys General Jill D. Brenner and Amanda L. Raimondi under Buffalo Regional Director Paul C. Parisi…