Sanibel’s Colony Inn Reopens After Three-Year Hurricane Ian Rebuild

Staff, owners and community members gathered at 419 East Gulf Drive on Sanibel Island’s eastern end this week for a SanCap Chamber ribbon-cutting marking the full comeback of the Colony Inn, a 36-unit condominium resort that sat closed for nearly three years after Hurricane Ian tore through the island. The celebration, held Wednesday, also marked the start of the property’s first full season since it reopened in fall 2025.

Hurricane Ian caused extensive damage to the Colony Inn’s buildings, guest accommodations, landscaping and common areas when it struck in September 2022, according to Gulfshore Business. The resort, established in 1969, has since undergone extensive renovations, with updated furnishings and décor meant to preserve its original character. Colony Inn general manager Marcie Allen said the work was designed to keep the property appealing to generations of returning guests.

36 Units, One Rental Program

The Colony Inn comprises 36 individually owned condominium units, 34 of which are part of its rental program, per the outlet’s reporting. All 36 units were renovated along with the resort’s common areas. A Sanibel-Captiva Chamber of Commerce member page notes that each unit was completely renovated following the storm, and that the Colony Inn has since been named a 2026 Best of Florida Regional Winner.

The property’s reopening fits into a broader pattern of island hospitality businesses clawing back from Hurricane Ian’s damage. The Anchor Inn & Cottages on Sanibel held its own SanCap Chamber ribbon-cutting on Jan. 20, 2026, after owners restored all 12 units while keeping their vintage charm, according to Captiva Sanibel. That property began accepting reservations Feb. 1 and was made more storm-resilient with raised equipment and impact windows.

More Island Properties Complete Their Rebuilds

Sanibel Beach Club II celebrated the full completion of its rebuild with its own ribbon-cutting on June 18, 2026, after welcoming owners back since August 2025 even as its pool and jacuzzi remained offline until the work wrapped up, Captiva Sanibel reported. Beachview Villas followed with an Aug. 5 ribbon-cutting after opening May 21 following a complete teardown of the former Beachview Cottages, according to the Sanibel-Captiva Chamber of Commerce. That property retained its original 22-unit count, including 10 junior suites, 11 one-bedroom suites and a four-bedroom, four-bath unit called the Junonia…

Story continues

TRENDING NOW

LATEST LOCAL NEWS