Indiana might surprise you if you’ve never hunted down a solid plate of pasta here. Around almost every corner, there’s a family-run Italian spot where the owners know your name and remember your favorite order.
You walk in, smell the garlic and tomato sauce, and instantly feel like you’ve stepped into someone’s kitchen instead of a restaurant.
Friends gather here for long talks over lasagna, and locals don’t think twice about calling ahead for a table. Indiana may be quiet about it, but it’s got some seriously good Italian comfort waiting for you.
1. Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Restaurant, Indianapolis
Walking into this place feels like stepping into someone’s home for Sunday dinner. The Carolla family opened their doors back in 1933, and the recipes haven’t changed much since then…