Indianapolis might not be the first place you think of when craving authentic New York-style bagels, but Bagel Fair has been proving skeptics wrong since 1975. Tucked into a strip mall at 1300 E 86th St, this family-run gem has built a loyal following over nearly five decades by doing one thing exceptionally well: making bagels the old-fashioned way.
Every morning, fresh bagels emerge from the ovens with that perfect combination of chewy texture and tender crumb that bagel lovers dream about.
What sets Bagel Fair apart isn’t just the quality of their bagels, though those are undeniably excellent. It’s the incredible variety of cream cheese spreads that transform a simple bagel into a breakfast you’ll crave every single day…