In 2015, Madison McGhee graduated from the College of Charledtin with a Bachelors Degree in Communications at age 19. Yet, her legacy goes much further than the footprints left at Cistern Yard. Madison learned a decade after her father’s death that his alleged heart attack was, in truth, a homicide and she needed answers. Here is her story:
Madison McGhee’s story is one of relentless determination, personal loss, and the power of storytelling to seek justice. As the creator and host of the podcast Ice Cold Case, Madison has transformed her grief into a public investigation, hoping to solve the 2002 murder of her father, John Cornelius “J.C.” McGhee, who was shot and killed in his home in Belmont County, Ohio.
Madison grew up believing her father had died of a heart attack, a story she was told as a child. It wasn’t until she was sixteen that she learned the truth: her father had been murdered, and the case remained unsolved. The revelation was life-altering. Her father, a former drug dealer and confidential informant, left behind a complicated legacy and a case that local law enforcement seemed unwilling or unable to solve. The lack of progress and transparency from the Belmont County Sheriff’s Department fueled Madison’s skepticism and frustration. She believed that her father’s background contributed to the case being deprioritized, leaving her family with unanswered questions and no closure.
Madison’s journey toward becoming an advocate for her father’s case began in earnest in the late 2010s. Inspired by the impact of true crime podcasts—such as those that helped bring the Golden State Killer to justice—she realized that public attention could breathe new life into cold cases. During the pandemic in 2020, she decided to fully commit to investigating her father’s murder, using her skills as an independent video producer to launch Ice Cold Case…