The city of Charlotte is asking a judge to dismiss a wrongful death lawsuit brought by the family of Iryna Zarutska, arguing that governmental immunity shields it from liability. The family sued the city and its private security contractor, Professional Police Services, after the 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee was killed aboard a light rail train, as reported by the New York Post.
Zarutska was killed in August 2025 after leaving her shift at a local pizzeria. Surveillance footage showed the suspect, Decarlos Brown Jr., sitting behind her on the Lynx Blue Line train before he allegedly stabbed her in the neck about four minutes after she boarded. Brown has been charged with murder and is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
In a 34-page filing submitted to a Mecklenburg County Superior Court judge, the city admitted several points about security on the transit system. Charlotte acknowledged that no private security guard was inside the train car during the attack. The city also said the light rail system has no turnstiles or fare gates and that Brown apparently boarded without presenting a ticket or pass.
The city still says it isn’t to blame
Despite these admissions, the city maintains that it is not responsible for the death of Zarutska, who had come to the US as a refugee. Charlotte argues that its decisions on transit policing, crime prevention, oversight of security contractors, and public safety administration are government functions protected by governmental immunity under North Carolina law. The city also argued that Brown alone is responsible, saying his failure to pay a fare did not signal that he would commit an attack.
The family anticipated this defense in their lawsuit. They argue that the city waived its immunity by running a light rail system that collects fares, which they contend is a proprietary function. Their complaint claims that physical barriers, stricter fare enforcement, and better security could have prevented the stabbing of the Ukrainian refugee…