North Carolina’s all-you-can-eat scene is richer than many travelers realize, with beloved community spots that quietly keep locals coming back. This list highlights operating restaurants with strong neighborhood followings, from coastal seafood spreads to homestyle country buffets and Asian super buffets. You’ll find practical details, seasonal notes, and what regulars say makes each place worth the trip. If you want real-deal North Carolina comfort without the tourist gloss, start here.
1. Casey’s Buffet (Wilmington)
Locals in Wilmington point to Casey’s Buffet for a classic all-you-can-eat Southern lineup and consistent service. The buffet focuses on regional staples such as fried chicken, barbecue, stewed vegetables, and scratch-made sides that feel like Sunday lunch.
Regulars mention the staff’s steady pace and quick replenishing as a reason the place stays busy on weekends. The space is unpretentious, with a straightforward dining room and a familiar crowd of families and longtime residents. Travelers appreciate that the spread reflects Eastern North Carolina flavors without overcomplicating the menu.
There is usually a short wait at peak times, which many locals accept as normal. If you care most about reliable, homestyle food and a neighborly atmosphere, Casey’s fits well. It has served the community for years and remains a dependable choice for groups. Check current hours before visiting, especially around holidays.
2. Robbins Nest (Selma)
Robbins Nest is a country buffet in Selma that residents treat like a weekly ritual. The lineup leans into straightforward comfort: fried chicken, fish, barbecue, and rotating vegetables prepared in a no-frills style. The dining room is casual and relaxed, which suits the steady flow of families and base personnel from nearby MCAS Cherry Point…