Sharing is caring!
Ohio has a pizza scene that can go toe-to-toe with any state in the country. From wood-fired Neapolitan pies in Columbus to old-school New York slices in Cleveland and creative Roman-style cuts in Cincinnati, there is something for every kind of pizza lover.
Whether you grew up eating square-cut cracker-thin crusts or you are always hunting for the next big topping combination, Ohio delivers. Get ready to plan your next road trip around these 12 incredible pizzerias worth every bite in 2026.
Paulie Gee’s Short North – Columbus, OH
Walking into Paulie Gee’s Short North feels like stepping into a Brooklyn pizzeria that somehow landed on Columbus’s trendiest street. Located at 1195 N High St in the Short North Arts District, this spot is a sibling of the beloved Brooklyn original and brings serious Neapolitan wood-fired pizza energy to central Ohio…