Ohio’s pizza scene is something special, with hidden spots serving up slices that locals have been enjoying for decades. These aren’t the big chain restaurants you see everywhere – they’re family-owned treasures with secret recipes and devoted followings.
I’m sharing twelve incredible pizzerias that Ohioans would rather keep to themselves.
1. Rubino’s Pizza
Since opening its doors in 1954, this Columbus gem has perfected the art of paper-thin rectangular pizza. You’ll find crispy edges, tangy sauce, and gooey provolone working together in perfect harmony.
The cash-only policy and simple decor transport you back in time. Locals have been guarding this secret for nearly 70 years, and once you taste it, you’ll understand why.
2. Terita’s Pizza
Walking into this 1959 establishment feels like visiting a friend’s kitchen where magic happens. The cheese gets perfectly caramelized around the edges, creating those crispy bits everyone fights over…