In a city where barbecue joints are as common as cowboy hats, it takes a lot to stand out. But sometimes, a place stands out for the wrong reasons—or so says Reddit. Enter Soulman’s Bar-B-Que, a local chain that has sparked fiery debates as heated as the pits their brisket comes from. Located at 8018 S Lancaster Rd, this spot has been labeled everything from “an abomination to barbecue” to “the best thing since sliced brisket.” So, what’s the real deal?
Let’s start with the not-so-sweet sauce.
Scroll through Reddit threads about Dallas BBQ, and you’ll quickly find some brutal takes on Soulman’s. One commenter didn’t hold back, calling it “the most disgusting thing I’ve ever eaten.” Another claimed it barely edges out “boiled BBQ from New York” (ouch). Catering, it seems, is also a sore subject—one disgruntled partygoer described a staff Christmas party catered by Soulman’s as “the worst decision ever.”
And the complaints don’t stop at flavor. Portion sizes and service have been major sticking points. One reviewer went so far as to accuse staff of skimping on meat, saving leftovers for themselves, and being generally “sarcastic” and “stingy.” Their final verdict? “Will never, ever go back.” Double-barrel potatoes, thin turkey slices, and skimpy sausage portions have all taken their share of heat.
But not all Redditors are ready to cancel Soulman’s.
Amid the flames of criticism, there are embers of loyalty. Some diners have called Soulman’s their go-to, vouching for its hearty portions and mouthwatering flavors. One fan, who admits they might have “trash taste,” swears by the Lancaster and I-20 location. Another raved about the baked potato with chopped beef and mac and cheese, a combo they enjoyed so much they couldn’t finish. Plus, let’s not overlook the undeniable allure of free ice cream.
Soulman’s may be divisive, but isn’t that the beauty of barbecue? What one person finds bland, another might find comforting. And let’s be real—any restaurant that’s been around for decades has to be doing something right. So whether you’re a seasoned skeptic or a devoted fan, Soulman’s remains a BBQ battleground worth visiting.
After all, in a city that takes its smoked meats seriously, even the “worst” barbecue is still better than no barbecue at all.