At a Glance: Stuart’s Top Pizza Spots
- The Pizza Gene and Vesuvio’s Pizzeria lead the pack with 4.7 ratings and strong local followings
- Salerno Pizza earns 4.7 stars across 836 reviews, with standout delivery and catering
- Pusateri’s Chicago Pizza is the go-to for authentic Chicago-style thin crust
- Piatto Divino offers the most upscale, imported-ingredient Neapolitan experience
- Ian & Kye’s Pizza is the newest standout with a perfect 5.0 rating
Artisan and Craft Pizza: Stuart’s Highest-Rated Spots
The Pizza Gene
The Pizza Gene on SE Monterey Road consistently draws the strongest praise of any pizza in Stuart, with reviewers citing owner Pat’s hands-on approach and the quality of every ingredient as the defining difference.
📍 424 SE Monterey Rd, Stuart, FL 34994 📞 (772) 888-3338 🌐 pizzagene.com 🍕 Must-Try: The Abomination pizza, any daily slice
Local Buzz: Regulars emphasize that the dough is light, airy, chewy, and blistered correctly, and that Pat personally checks on tables and remembers faces. One reviewer called it “the best pizza in the area by a mile.” A small outdoor space is available for dine-in.
Vesuvio’s Pizzeria
Vesuvio’s Pizzeria on SE Federal Highway is a neighborhood anchor with 655 reviews and a 4.7 rating. It is known for its scratch-made Italian breads, pastries, and a counter loaded with rainbow cookies and other Italian sweets.
View this post on Instagram
A post shared by Foodbros (@foodbrosss)…