Additional Coverage:
- Meghan Markle’s show Emmy nomination ‘somewhat baffling’ due to ‘lackluster’ ratings: expert (foxnews.com)
Meghan Markle’s Netflix series, “With Love, Meghan,” has received an Emmy nomination, sparking mixed reactions and some surprise among industry observers.
Despite the show’s cancellation months ago, the Duchess of Sussex celebrated her first Emmy nod on Instagram, congratulating the team behind the lifestyle series for their recognition in the Outstanding Lifestyle Series category.
However, some experts find the nomination puzzling given the show’s modest reception. British royal commentator Hilary Fordwich described the decision as “somewhat baffling,” pointing to the series’ low viewership and lukewarm audience response. She suggested that the nomination may reflect the tendency of award bodies to favor high-profile figures rather than commercial success.
Fordwich further noted that while the nomination offers valuable publicity, it doesn’t guarantee a solid media future for Markle’s projects. “This would only be a public-relations win, which is a far cry from a concrete future media contract,” she said.
Similarly, YouTube host Kinsey Schofield acknowledged the nomination’s value as a form of industry validation but cautioned against overstating its impact. She emphasized that consistent audience engagement and reliable project delivery remain key to long-term success in entertainment. Schofield also pointed out that the show’s popularity on social media, particularly TikTok parodies, outpaced its Netflix viewership.
Public relations expert Doug Eldridge highlighted the lasting prestige that comes with an Emmy nomination, regardless of the show’s ratings or whether Markle wins. “She will always be introduced as ‘Emmy nominated actress and lifestyle personality, Meghan Markle’,” Eldridge said, comparing the accolade to an athlete’s lifelong status as an Olympian. He added that while the nomination may not enhance her standing within the industry, it provides a valuable boost to her public image and lifestyle brand.
“When ‘With Love, Meghan’ debuted in March 2025, it faced mostly negative critical reviews, earning a 38% score on Rotten Tomatoes and generally unfavorable marks on Metacritic. Nevertheless, strong initial viewer interest led Netflix to approve a second season, which premiered in August 2025.”
Markle’s first Emmy win will be revealed at the 53rd Annual Daytime Emmy Awards on October 30, 2026, in Los Angeles. For now, the nomination itself serves as a notable milestone in her evolving career beyond the royal spotlight.