Some meals earn a reputation that travels far past the county line, and this counter-serve spot in West Orange has done exactly that since the early 1930s. Regulars will happily point you toward the door, then half-jokingly ask you to keep the secret so the line stays short.
What makes it worth the drive is a sandwich so oversized you can hold it with two hands, built on soft pizza bread and stacked with layers most places would split into two orders. People road-trip in from Maryland, Jersey City, and even fly back from Florida just to relive the taste.
The story behind the name runs deep, the prices stay friendly, and the folks behind the counter treat first-timers like they have been coming for years. Here is everything worth knowing before you go.
A Counter Classic Tucked Into West Orange
Down a stretch of Washington Street sits a no-frills spot that has quietly built a statewide following. You will find Jimmy Buff’s Of West Orange Italian Hot Dogs at 60 Washington St, West Orange, New Jersey 07052, and the address is worth writing down before you set out…