Scottsdale Woman’s Trial in Trevor Bauer Fraud Case Put on Hold by Court

An Arizona Court of Appeals order has paused the fraud prosecution of Scottsdale woman Darcy Adanna Esemonu, with jury selection scheduled to begin just four days later. The November 5 stay came as Esemonu faced two felony counts of fraudulent schemes and artifices involving former Major League Baseball pitcher Trevor Bauer and another man.

Prosecutors accuse Esemonu of defrauding Bauer by falsely claiming she was pregnant and asking him for money, according to court records obtained by 12News. Bauer has alleged that she demanded $1.6 million in exchange for getting an abortion, CNN previously reported. Bauer has also alleged that Esemonu sought $3.6 million and that he paid her $8,761 for pregnancy-related expenses in 2023; those figures are claims by Bauer and his attorneys.

The criminal case followed a civil lawsuit Esemonu filed against Bauer in June 2023, accusing him of assaulting her several times, including sexually assaulting her in December 2020, according to CNN. Her original complaint alleged choking, physical violence and threats involving a knife, and sought roughly $3.69 million in damages. Bauer has denied sexually assaulting her and said their encounter was consensual. He has also said Esemonu was never pregnant and that her medical records support that claim. In an April 2024 video, Bauer acknowledged her indictment and said, “One of the women who accused me of sexual assault just got indicted for committing felony fraud against me. Imagine that.”

How a Charging Dispute Derailed the Original Trial Date

The appellate dispute centers on prosecutors’ effort to revise the original indictment. That indictment combined allegations involving Bauer and another alleged victim, and the case was set for trial on April 13, 2026. Before that date, prosecutors sought to change the indictment’s wording, but Judge Kristin Culbertson rejected the proposed amendment as substantive rather than technical, according to 12News…

Story continues

TRENDING NOW

LATEST LOCAL NEWS