A Cleveland County judge has sanctioned State Farm and ordered company executives to testify live before a Norman jury, after a hail-damaged roof turned into a fight over documents.
Don and Brenda Foster sued in 2023, after a low offer on a house the storm had left leaking. Their lawyers want a January trial to reach past one inspection, into internal replacement targets and a consulting firm they say helped shape how claims get handled. Judge Thad Balkman issued the sanctions to push State Farm to comply with court orders, KFOR reported Monday. The company has to produce documents before the case goes to trial, and executives who have already testified in depositions will have to do it again, live, in Norman.
What the Order Requires
Balkman’s order sets a sequence, not a verdict. State Farm has to produce documents before the Foster case heads to trial in January 2027. Executives who have already given depositions must then testify live before the jury in Norman. Accenture, the consulting company drawn into the lawsuit, must send a live witness to Oklahoma for a deposition before trial.
Nick Marr, an attorney for the Fosters, said Balkman had exhausted his options after months of patience. Jeff Marr, founder of Marr Law Firm and also representing the couple, accused State Farm of withholding documents and evidence and of not complying with court orders. He said documents and testimony withheld under privilege will become public record after the order. He recalled that he had not seen this kind of order in a State Farm case since the 2006 Watkins class action…