In May 2025, school leaders in South Hadley discovered that the town’s high school had been vandalized. Three young people had broken in, smashed stage lights in the auditorium, and caused some $2,500 in damage.
As police set about investigating the case, they ran into dead ends with the low-quality surveillance footage they pulled from cameras in the parking lot of a bank and at a 7-Eleven on the night of the crime. And that’s when town Detective Christopher Roberts contacted the New England State Police Intelligence Sharing Network to get access to a much more powerful — and controversial — technology: facial recognition software.
Robbins obtained a search warrant from Eastern Hampshire District Court, and submitted a request to state police to search the Registry of Motor Vehicles database of ID photos. The search found no matches, even though investigators submitted a “clarified” version of an image cropped from a CCTV camera with adjustments to brightness and contrast, in an attempt to highlight the suspect’s face…