Montgomery County commissioners voted 13-8 to approve a resolution allowing the county to acquire a small strip of Hickory Wild homeowners association land, using eminent domain if necessary, to finally connect both ends of John Duke Tyler Boulevard. The vote came after weeks of pushback from HOA leaders who said they had not even seen a purchase offer before the county moved toward condemnation.
A Gap Blocking Emergency Vehicles and School Buses
According to Main Street Media of Tennessee, the parcel at the center of the dispute creates a gap in John Duke Tyler Boulevard that blocks through traffic and limits access for emergency vehicles and school buses. The road was originally built as a collector road, and the Farmington and Wellington Fields subdivisions both rely on it, per the outlet’s reporting. The Hickory Wild subdivision itself was approved back in August 2007, but the boulevard still does not connect through its interior, the article notes.
The resolution the commission passed is broken into three sections: the first two address a declaration of necessity and authorization to acquire the property, while the third authorizes the county to pursue condemnation through eminent domain if negotiations with the HOA break down, per the same report. Regional Planning Commission Director Jeff Tyndall told commissioners the connection is needed for residential through traffic, first responders and school buses, and he said, according to ClarksvilleNow, that the county has every intention of making a good faith effort in negotiating before any condemnation proceeding would begin.
HOA Says It Was Left in the Dark
Hickory Wild HOA vice president Katie Johnson told the county the HOA had not yet received a written purchase offer, an appraisal, survey, legal description, or proposed acquisition agreement, ClarksvilleNow reported from a Nov. 6 meeting where the item was pulled from the consent agenda so discussion could continue into the following week. The parcel is owned by the Hickory Wild Homeowners Association and covers roughly 0.02 acres, per Main Street Media of Tennessee’s reporting. The outlet reported the parcel measures 10 feet wide and 100 feet long, while ClarksvilleNow separately reported the property amounts to 1,006 square feet — the two outlets gave differing figures for the same strip of land.
Commissioner Joshua Beal tried to strip out the condemnation authority entirely. He moved to remove Section 3 and instead have the county obtain an appraisal before negotiating a purchase price with the HOA, arguing that the HOA owns the parcel and the county should consider its wishes. Beal said the commission could always return to Section 3 later if negotiations failed, but his motion failed by a 9-12 vote, according to ClarksvilleNow. A separate attempt by Commissioner Nathan Burkholder to defer the whole resolution for one month also failed, voted down 6-15, the outlet reported.
Safety Arguments Carried the Vote
Commissioner Cydney Daane argued at the Nov. 9 meeting that an alternate route could help responders reach families faster in medical emergencies and give residents a way out, according to ClarksvilleNow’s account. She said the safety of the community, especially children, cannot be priced. The resolution ultimately passed with support from commissioners John Gannon, Ted Denny, Joe Smith, Rickey Ray, Rashidah Leverett, Clayton Rudder, Burkholder, Luther Hutchenson, Walker Woodruff, David Harper, Lisa Prichard, Chris Rasnic and Daane herself…