For 43 years, there’s been one place in Madison that bakers — amateur and professional alike — have been able to count on for their supplies. In a fluorescent-lit storefront on Odana Road, Vanilla Bean had stocked everything from cake boxes to just about any cookie cutter shape, food dye color and type of sprinkles a person could imagine. But this past spring, a major rent hike introduced by new building ownership threatened to cut off that local supply permanently.
Hundreds of followers on Facebook reacted to the news of Vanilla Bean’s imminent closure. “I think, like so many other people in the community, my first thought was, ‘This cannot happen,’ ” says Kate Teasdale, who visited the shop as a child with her mother, a bread-dough clay crafter. “It’s been such an important part of the community for so long. It’s been part of family celebrations and birthdays and memories for years — including mine.”
So Teasdale and her husband, Chuck (both former owners of the Riley Tavern in Verona), decided to do something about it. They purchased the business and relocated it to Middleton’s Hubbard Avenue, where they’ve spent the past six months working with Destree Design Architects to build out Vanilla Bean’s modern and colorful new home.
The revamp includes green wallpaper patterned with vanilla bean plants, and features butter yellow and bright yellow subway tile accents throughout the space. Aluminum cake molds from the original shop border the upper walls against a strip of sky-blue paint, and light fixtures modeled after yellow vanilla bean flowers hang from the ceiling. The storefront looks out through large windows on Middleton’s Stone Horse Green, an outdoor event venue and gathering space.
Aside from the relocation and interior facelift, not much has changed. The Teasdales have remained true to everything that made Vanilla Bean popular, including its deep inventory and knowledgeable customer service. Several employees from the shop on Odana Road have rejoined the team, and former manager Kelly Bodie — who is also the daughter of original owners Jane and Tom Stunkard — has offered guidance on stocking shelves so customers can still expect to find the deep shelves of candymaking supplies, specialty chocolate, cake-decorating tips, piping bags and more.
“It’ll be an ongoing process to rebuild the massive, incredible inventory that they built over their 43 years in business,” says Kate Teasdale, but she’s hoping customers will let her know what the store is still missing. In the meantime, the Teasdales are planning to expand Vanilla Bean’s class offerings in early 2027, introducing 12-person workshops with a focus on baking, candymaking and decorating sweets.
Says Teasdale, “I have a feeling my baking skills are about to be kicked up a notch.”…