After an April 2020 hailstorm, an Iowa homeowner sought insurance coverage to replace the shingles on his half of a duplex. The owner of the other half had a different insurer and had that roof replaced. His own claim was denied, and he eventually paid for his half himself so the roofing work could proceed.
The first inspection, arranged by his insurer, found hail damage to roof vents and the furnace cap, but none to the shingles. The insurer put the damage below his deductible. The homeowner then hired an independent adjuster and a roofing contractor. Both said hail had damaged the roof and recommended replacing the shingles.
The insurer commissioned another inspection, this time from an engineering firm. Its engineer photographed the roof and attributed its condition to man-made damage, balding, aging and nail pops. He concluded that hail had not damaged it. The insurer again denied the claim, and the homeowner sued the insurer, the engineering firm and the engineer.
What each side argued
The homeowner argued that the engineering firm had improperly helped defeat his insurance claim. He said its definition of hail damage was narrower than the coverage in his policy. He also argued that the firm’s interest in getting repeat business from insurers explained its conclusion…