Naperville’s Planning and Zoning Commission voted 7-1 Wednesday to recommend City Council approval of a plan for 70 townhouses and two commercial outlots on five acres along Route 59, even as commissioners and a nearby resident raised concerns about how dense the project really is. The proposal, known as Madden Row, calls for a floor-area ratio that exceeds the limit allowed under city code, a detail that became a central point of debate before the commission signed off.
Naperville planners endorsed the plan for the southernmost five acres of the Design Pointe development on Route 59, just south of the shopping center, according to the Daily Herald. Madden Row is proposed by HSG Investments Naperville, an affiliate of Chicago-based Hubbard Street Group, and the project requires a major change to the 20-year-old Design Pointe development plan along with other entitlements. The developer’s requests include an increase to the floor-area ratio, which the Daily Herald reports already exceeds what city code allows.
A Pond That Skews the Math
That floor-area ratio calculation excludes a 3.7-acre pond that provides stormwater detention for the site, according to the same report. Kage Brown, representing the developer, said the pond makes the FAR measurement appear potentially inflated — an argument meant to explain why the numbers look more intense than the project feels on the ground. HSG Investments Naperville has described the proposed density as approximately 18 dwelling units per acre.
The project has already been scaled back once. Per Brown, HSG Investments Naperville reduced the planned townhouse units from 75 to 70 and removed all four-bedroom units after feedback from School District 204 and nearby residents. The revised plan shifted to place townhouses on most of the five-acre site while preserving slightly more than an acre of business space along the major road, the Daily Herald reported.
Why the Site Didn’t Stay Commercial
Hubbard Street Group marketed the site to retail, restaurant and medical tenants for more than a year before proposing the shift away from a purely commercial use, per Brown. Site characteristics discouraged potential tenants, the report notes, including the lack of a signalized Route 59 intersection and the property’s long east-west depth away from the road itself…