The former president of the Sevier County Utility District has pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit bribery, theft of property over $10,000, and theft of services over $10,000 after waiving his right to a jury trial, admitting to a scheme that investigators say involved more than $181,000 in total misappropriation from the gas utility, including kickbacks and misused employee labor. Matthew Ballard asked the court to decide his guilt and punishment on November 12, eight days earlier.
From Indictment to Guilty Plea
Ballard was indicted in January 2025 on charges of bribery of a public servant and official misconduct following what officials described as a lengthy misconduct investigation, according to WGRV. As reported by WBIR, Ballard ultimately pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit bribery, theft of property over $10,000, and theft of services over $10,000. His father, William Edgar Ballard, had also faced a charge of criminal responsibility for the conduct of another when the indictment was handed down in January 2025.
The Mountain Press reported a somewhat different charge configuration in its account of the plea agreement, describing guilty pleas to conspiracy to commit bribery, theft of property worth more than $1,000, and theft of service over $10,000. Each of Ballard’s charges is a class C felony that can carry up to four years in the Tennessee Department of Correction, meaning he could face up to 12 years in prison total under the plea.
What Prosecutors Agreed to Recommend
As part of the deal, the state agreed to recommend an eight-year suspended sentence to supervised probation, conditioned on Ballard having no unconsented contact with witnesses, per the WBIR report. Prosecutors also agreed to recommend restitution of $154,800 tied to the theft charges and to drop a separate conspiracy to commit bribery charge. The court still must consider Ballard’s recommendation to plead guilty, and he is set to return to court in January 2027.
The Mountain Press reported additional payment terms not confirmed in the WBIR account: $100,000 due on the date of plea entry, with the remaining $54,800 balance to be paid at $571 per month. That outlet also reported Ballard’s probation term and restitution figure matched the $154,800 total described by WBIR.
How the Scheme Allegedly Worked
The investigation began after 4th Judicial District Attorney General James Dunn asked the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation and the Tennessee Comptroller’s Office to look into misappropriation at the utility district, according to WBIR. Investigators alleged Ballard provided electrical construction work to a company in exchange for personal monetary contributions, and that he requested the company overbill the district while funneling kickbacks back to him or his father. The Tennessee Comptroller’s Office reported that Ballard misappropriated at least $181,500 from the utility district, with the kickback scheme alone accounting for over $158,000 of that total, according to the comptroller’s figures cited by WBIR…