Former Caldwell Police Chief Rex Ingram has filed a nine-page supplemental notice of tort claim accusing Mayor Eric Phillips of helping release city hall security footage that he says was then twisted by online posts into false accusations that he was a sexual predator. The footage, Ingram says, shows nothing more than him and a city employee apparently conversing and hugging in a hallway. The filing, submitted to the Idaho Secretary of State’s office on Nov. 18, builds on the three-page tort claim Ingram originally filed in May 2026.
Ingram’s original claim, filed May 28, accused Mayor Eric Phillips and unnamed city officials of political retaliation, harassment, threats and defamation, and interference with his employment rights, according to the Idaho Statesman. He is seeking more than $500,000 for lost wages, retirement benefits, emotional distress and reputational harm, per the seed reporting from KTVB. Caldwell denied that original claim on June 5, with the city’s denial letter stating the notice failed to identify facts establishing liability against the city or its officials, and the Idaho Statesman separately reported the city called the claims a baseless demand on taxpayer resources.
Footage, Online Posts, and a Mayor’s Public Comments
According to the supplemental filing, Ingram says online posts falsely described the hallway footage as sexual misconduct and labeled him a sexual predator, and that those posts came down about 20 minutes after Ingram told Phillips they had to stop. The supplemental claim alleges, based on information and belief rather than direct evidence, that Phillips was involved in releasing the footage. Ingram believes Phillips helped release the security footage, per the filing.
Phillips told the city council on Aug. 3 that there was an active personnel investigation regarding the video, and he announced his own retirement eight days after that meeting. Ingram announced his retirement on Aug. 11, and the supplemental claim alleges the city constructively discharged him effective Sept. 1 — the same date Councilmember Geoff Williams apologized to Ingram at his retirement ceremony. Ingram claims, per the tort claim, that he was forced out and that his fall retirement was not voluntary; he has not filed a lawsuit over the claims.
Spending Feuds and a Halted Internal Affairs Probe
The supplemental filing also details a running dispute over police department spending and oversight. Per the filing, Phillips suggested Ingram wasted public money, publishing a Facebook post in December 2025 about spending on Idaho Steelheads suites, restaurants and training, and another in May 2026 calling past spending a wildly inappropriate use of taxpayer dollars. Phillips also said, per the filing, that the city could afford a bridge if the police department had not cost it so much money. A special prosecutor had already declined to file charges over Ingram’s spending in both July 2024 and March 2025…