On October 9, 1989, a grim discovery in the woods near an old oyster factory in Fernandina Beach, Florida, set in motion a mystery that would puzzle investigators for decades. A local stumbled upon a unusual sight: a human skull resting inside a bucket, hidden among the trees. The location, just 4.2 miles south of A1A off State Road 107, seemed an odd final resting place for someone’s remains. Now, 35 years later, the questions still remain: Who was this person? How did they end up here?