Additional Coverage:
- Clemency bid rejected for Texas man set to be first U.S. execution for ‘shaken baby’ death (nbcnews.com)
Condemned Man’s Execution Pending
A Texas board has denied clemency for Robert Roberson, who is scheduled to be executed Thursday for “shaken baby syndrome.” This case marks the potential first execution in the nation for this diagnosis.
Medical Evidence Questioned
Roberson’s legal team argues that new evidence shows his daughter’s death in 2002 was not caused by abuse but by natural causes. The science behind “shaken baby syndrome” has faced scrutiny, with many medical professionals now recognizing that similar symptoms can be caused by other conditions.
Governor’s Decision Pending
While the board denied clemency, Governor Greg Abbott can still postpone the execution. He has not yet responded to requests for comment. Roberson’s case highlights concerns about the use of outdated medical science in criminal convictions.
Ongoing Debate
The Roberson case has sparked a debate over the reliability of shaken baby syndrome diagnoses. Since 1992, at least 34 people in the US have had their convictions vacated based on this diagnosis.
Detective’s Change of Heart
Brian Wharton, the detective who arrested Roberson, now believes he is innocent. He acknowledges that he was unaware of Roberson’s autism diagnosis and Nikki’s medical history when he made the arrest.
Support for Roberson
Roberson’s case has garnered support from scientists, doctors, legislators, and advocates for parental rights and people with autism. They urge Governor Abbott to halt the execution and consider the new medical evidence.