Additional Coverage:
- 7 Best Frozen Chicken Pot Pies at the Grocery Store (cheapism.com)
Frozen Chicken Pot Pie Power Ranking: From Freezer Staple to Gourmet Surprise
Let’s be honest, a frozen chicken pot pie is a lifesaver. Whether it’s a weeknight dinner shortcut or a comforting solo meal, these freezer aisle staples always hit the spot.
But which one reigns supreme? We’ve consulted taste tests, reviews, and even passionate Reddit threads to bring you the definitive ranking of frozen chicken pot pies.
The Classics:
- Marie Callender’s: This is the OG, the gold standard, the frozen pot pie against which all others are measured. Its flaky, golden crust and creamy, savory filling packed with chicken, peas, carrots, and potatoes make it a crowd-pleaser. While the family-size version might skimp a bit on the chicken, the single-serve portions are perfect for a quick meal.
- Stouffer’s: A reliable backup for when Marie Callender’s is out of stock, Stouffer’s offers a similar experience with its double-crust pie and classic filling. While the crust can sometimes be a bit chewy, the generous chicken portion and rich sauce make it a satisfying choice.
Regional Favorite:
- Willow Tree: A New England classic, Willow Tree boasts a devoted following in its region. Known for its ample chicken and balanced filling-to-crust ratio, this pie is a hidden gem for those lucky enough to find it.
The Unexpected:
- Trader Joe’s Handheld Chicken Pot Pie: Leave it to Trader Joe’s to reinvent the wheel (or in this case, the pie). These handheld, empanada-like creations are a fun twist on the classic. Just be warned, they’re a bit dry – a glass of water is highly recommended.
Healthier Option:
- Healthy Choice Crustless Chicken Pot Pie: For those seeking a lighter option, Healthy Choice offers a crustless version that’s more akin to a stew. While it might not deliver the same pie experience, it’s a guilt-free way to enjoy the classic flavors.
Gourmet Contender:
- “By Chef Ramsay” Chicken Pot Pie: Yes, that Gordon Ramsay. This Walmart-exclusive pie features a puff pastry top and a filling with mushrooms and other veggies, elevating it beyond the standard frozen fare. Reviews praise the flaky crust and tender chicken.
All-Natural Choice:
- Blake’s Chicken Pot Pie: This smaller, top-crust-only pie focuses on natural ingredients and a less processed flavor. Fans appreciate the buttery, crisp crust and wholesome ingredients.
Read More About This Story:
- 7 Best Frozen Chicken Pot Pies at the Grocery Store (cheapism.com)