Additional Coverage:
Jury Selection Underway in High-Profile Texas Murder Trial
Jury selection has officially commenced in the highly anticipated murder trial of Sarah Hartsfield, the Texas woman accused of fatally poisoning her fifth husband, Joseph Hartsfield, with insulin. The proceedings mark a significant development in a case that has captured widespread attention across the state.
Hartsfield, 50, has pleaded not guilty to the charge of murder. Prosecutors allege in a grand jury indictment, filed in February 2023, that she “intentionally and knowingly cause[d] the death of an individual, namely Joseph Hartsfield, by a manner and means unknown to the grand jury.”
Joseph Hartsfield died in January 2023. His obituary stated he died in a hospital “due to complications of an ischemic stroke, with his loving wife at his side,” a detail that starkly contrasts with later allegations.
Sarah Hartsfield is currently held in Chambers County Jail on a reduced bond of $2 million.
Prosecutors contend that Hartsfield, an Army veteran, exploited her husband’s diabetes to conceal a homicide. They allege she injected him with dangerous amounts of insulin and deliberately delayed calling emergency services for several hours.
Joseph Hartsfield was ultimately hospitalized and died days later. Investigators reportedly discovered multiple insulin pens near his bedside and noted inconsistencies in Sarah Hartsfield’s statements.
Chambers County Sheriff Brian Hawthorne commented on the initial investigation, stating, “I appreciate the hard work of the deputies and detectives who followed their instincts and identified the suspicious circumstances surrounding Mr. Hartsfield’s death that could have been labeled as ‘death due to illness’ instead of murder.”
The defense maintains that Joseph Hartsfield’s death may have been a tragic complication of his pre-existing medical condition, rather than a deliberate act by his wife.
Adding a layer of complexity to the case is Sarah Hartsfield’s extensive marital history. The now 48-year-old has been married five times, with several relationships marked by legal issues and controversy.
Her first marriage, to high school sweetheart Titus Knoernschild, ended in divorce by 1995. Knoernschild reported receiving threats from Hartsfield during their separation and ongoing harassment for years, leading him to obtain a no-contact order in 2008.
Her second marriage in the mid-1990s saw her arrested in March 1996 for allegedly assaulting her husband during a domestic dispute; the charge was later dropped. Her third marriage concluded in divorce in 2018.
Around that same time, she was engaged to David Bragg in Minnesota. On May 9, 2018, Hartsfield shot and killed Bragg in his home, claiming self-defense.
Douglas County prosecutors ruled the killing justifiable at the time.
Not long after Bragg’s death, Hartsfield married her fourth husband in 2019, a union that also ended in divorce by 2021.
Her fifth marriage was to Joseph Hartsfield in 2022. Friends and neighbors told local media outlets that Joseph was unhappy in the marriage and had been planning to leave.
On January 7, 2023, he was found unresponsive following a diabetic emergency. Prosecutors allege Sarah injected him with excessive insulin and delayed calling 911.
He died days later, with the Harris County Medical Examiner ruling the cause of death as complications from toxic insulin exposure.
Sarah Hartsfield was arrested and indicted for Joseph’s murder in February 2023. Following jury selection, opening statements in the trial are scheduled to begin.