In a state famed for its taverns and their legendary burgers, calling one “the best” is a bold claim – and a challenge. Yet, consistently, the burger from The Old Fashioned on Pinckney Street rises to the top of every conversation, accumulating accolades that have made it known across Wisconsin and well beyond. Skeptical?
You should be. But there’s a reason this humble Madison eatery has achieved such widespread fame. This isn’t just hype; it’s a testament to culinary perfection that demands explanation.
Let’s dig into what makes this particular burger so universally celebrated.
Prime Location In Downtown Madison
Walking into The Old Fashioned feels like stepping into the heart of Wisconsin itself. Situated at 23 North Pinckney Street, this tavern sits directly across from the State Capitol building, making it impossible to miss during any downtown stroll…