Additional Coverage:
- I’ve Tried Dozens of Costco Cakes, but This One Is the Best (financebuzz.com)
Sweet Sensations: We Rank Costco’s Top Bakery Cakes
Costco members, rejoice! The warehouse giant is a treasure trove for budget-friendly delights, and their bakery aisle is no exception.
With so many tempting cakes on offer, choosing just one can feel like a delicious dilemma. But fear not, fellow dessert enthusiasts!
We’ve done the delectable legwork for you, sampling every sweet treat to crown the ultimate champion.
Editor’s Note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.
The Runners-Up: A Parade of Pastry Perfection
While only one can be king, these contenders are certainly worthy of a spot on your dessert table:
Kirkland Signature All Butter Pound Cake – Price: $6.99
Sometimes, simplicity reigns supreme.
This no-frills pound cake lives up to its name, boasting an abundance of real butter for a truly sumptuous sweet. Enjoy it plain, or elevate it with a dusting of powdered sugar, a scoop of vanilla ice cream, and a scattering of fresh berries.
A classic for a reason, and a fantastic value!
Kirkland Signature Lemon Blueberry Loaf Cake – Price: $10.20
This delightful loaf offers a subtle yet refreshing citrus kick, making it both sweet and bright. Its moist, blueberry-packed batter and a gourmet-like finish of lemon icing and buttery streusel make it perfect for brunch or as an after-dinner treat with fruit sorbet.
Kirkland Signature Caramel Tres Leche Bar Cake – Price: $17.99
For those who appreciate a tres leche with a bit more structure, this bar-shaped cake offers a welcome firmness.
Featuring sponge cake soaked in a trio of milks, creamy custard mousse, caramel whipped cream, and shaved chocolate, it’s a fan favorite. One Reddit user even declared, “I’d give up a kidney for a slice.
Pair it with an espresso shot.” We concur!
Kirkland Signature Plain Cheesecake – Price: $22.69
Don’t let the “plain” fool you – this 12-inch, four-pound cheesecake is a marvel of luscious, velvety texture.
While Costco offers fancier variations, this classic stands on its own. It’s also an incredible bargain; a whole cake for under $23 compared to nearly $11 for a single slice at some specialty bakeries.
Top it with your favorite fruits or sauces for a personalized touch.
Kirkland Signature Carrot Bar Cake – Price: $18.99
This mouthwatering dessert, brimming with cream cheese icing, raisins, toasted walnuts, pineapple, and, of course, carrots, is even a hit with Costco employees. As one Reddit user put it, “It’s really good, not super sweet…Very few things I get from my bakery, but I’d buy this.”
Kirkland Signature Tiramisu Cheesecake – Price: $23.99
Coffee lovers, prepare yourselves!
This sinfully sweet treat from the refrigerated bakery aisle features a chocolatey graham and cocoa crust, dreamy mascarpone whip topping, and a cold brew cheesecake center. A definite fan favorite, with one shopper calling it “the best dessert I’ve ever had from Costco.”
And don’t worry about finishing it all – extra slices freeze beautifully.
Kirkland Signature Chocolate Cake Filled with Chocolate Mousse – Price: $16.99
Coming in at a close second, this 10-inch round frosted cake is a chocolate lover’s dream.
With a velvety-soft base, ultra-fine crumb, and a thick, almost fudgy frosting, it’s a crowd-pleaser with surprising longevity. Available plain or decorated for any celebration!
And the Winner Is…
Kirkland Signature Tuxedo Chocolate Mousse Cake – Price: $21.55
It’s a classic for a reason! Layers of rich chocolate mousse, delicate vanilla mousse, and decadent white and dark chocolate ganache elevate this bakery buy to gourmet status, securing its spot at the very top of our list.
This mega-popular pick isn’t just our favorite; shoppers rave about its addictive qualities. As Redditor iforgothowtohuman emphatically warned, “Do not buy the tuxedo cake…unless you’re prepared to eat the whole thing yourself in maybe two or three days.
Because you will. I am.”
You’ve been warned!
The Bottom Line
There you have it! After much delicious deliberation, the iconic Kirkland Signature Tuxedo Chocolate Mousse Cake reigns supreme.
However, the competition was fierce, proving that when it comes to delicious, cost-effective desserts, Costco’s bakery is an absolute must-visit. These top-quality treats offer incredible value, making them perfect for any occasion.
And while you’re there, keep an eye out for other fantastic finds throughout the store – especially as new seasons approach!
Read More About This Story:
- I’ve Tried Dozens of Costco Cakes, but This One Is the Best (financebuzz.com)