Additional Coverage:
- 12 Costco Bakery Hidden Gems That Most Shoppers Miss (financebuzz.com)
Sweet Surprises: Uncovering Costco’s Best-Kept Bakery Secrets
Costco members know that the warehouse giant’s bakery section is a treasure trove of delightful desserts. From the highly praised Kirkland Signature tiramisu cheesecake to the ever-popular tuxedo bar and those famously massive cupcakes (we call them mini cakes!), there’s no shortage of sweet indulgences.
But while some treats bask in the spotlight, a few truly scrumptious options often fly under the radar. Our team took on the arduous (but delicious!) task of taste-testing our way through Costco’s bakery, and we’re thrilled to share some hidden gems that absolutely deserve your attention.
Here’s a look at some fantastic bakery desserts you might be overlooking on your next trip:
Editor’s Note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location and seasonality.
1. Kirkland Signature Strawberry Streusel Cheesecake – $22.99
Costco recently rolled out this new strawberry streusel cheesecake, and it’s a delightful surprise hiding in plain sight. Shoppers are already raving, with one Redditor noting, “I have zero regrets buying this…It reminds me of strawberry pretzel salad. It’s light and fresh, not super rich like many cheesecakes.”
2. Kirkland Signature Decorated Tuxedo Bar Cake – $17.99
You’re familiar with the classic, sleek Tuxedo Bar Cake, but did you know there are other versions? Keep an eye on the bakery section, especially during pre-holiday seasons, for specially decorated editions.
We even spotted a charming springtime version adorned with delicate frosting flowers. This fan-favorite layers rich chocolate cake, fluffy chocolate mousse, sweet white chocolate mousse, luxurious dark chocolate ganache, and chocolate cocoa nibs.
3. Kirkland Signature Cookie Trio – $9.99
Tired of just chocolate chip? This fantastic 24-pack offers a tasty trio that includes the original chocolate chip, along with often-overlooked buttery double nut and classic oatmeal raisin cookies.
While all three are enjoyed, the macadamia double nut sweets are a particular hit. As one Redditor put it, “Omg, these are ALWAYS the first row to disappear.”
Some lucky shoppers have even reportedly snagged entire boxes of just the macadamia nut variety!
4. Kirkland Signature Rugula – $10.99
You might walk right past these flaky, doughy Eastern European cookies while searching for more traditional treats, but don’t! Rugula isn’t typically found in most superstore bakeries, making this seasonal Costco find a true foodie discovery. The 25-ounce variety pack, featuring raspberry walnut, chocolate, and cream cheese fillings, is an incredible value.
5. Kirkland Signature Chocolate Chunk Cookies – $9.99
These aren’t your average “snack section” cookies. Costco’s premium take is generously packed with massive chunks of chocolate. While nearly $10 for a pack might seem steep, the quality and quantity easily justify the price when compared to similar, often un-freshly baked, brand-name alternatives.
6. Kirkland Signature Caramel Tres Leche Bar Cake – $17.99
Often overshadowed by its chocolate cousin, the tuxedo bar, this indulgent leche (milk) cake deserves a prime spot in your cart. This creamy, dreamy dessert, with its caramel, three-milk (evaporated, condensed, and whole/cream) custard, and sponge cake, isn’t available year-round or in all regions, so grab it if you see it!
7. Upper Crust Bakery Mini Lemon Bites – $8.79
While Kirkland Signature dominates the bakery, a little sleuthing can uncover other delightful treats. Our search through the sweets section yielded these refreshing Meyer lemon bites from Upper Crust Bakery. This seasonal product offers a perfectly balanced flavor profile – refreshingly sweet with a delightful hint of tart citrus.
8. Kirkland Signature Carrot Bar Cake – $18.99
The unexpected arrival of this new bar cake delighted shoppers. With its cream cheese icing, raisins, toasted walnuts, pineapple, and, of course, carrots, it offers a delicious and well-balanced alternative to overly rich chocolate and buttercream options.
9. Kirkland Signature Apple Pie – $12.99
While the new apple berry pie ($15.99) is generating buzz, pie purists shouldn’t forget the classic. For $3 less, you can enjoy the traditional, four-plus-pound all-apple version. If you prefer your pie unadorned, this is the pick for you.
10. Kirkland Signature All Butter Pound Cake – $6.99
Sometimes, simplicity reigns supreme. Don’t let the fancy lemon icing or blueberry additions of other loaf cakes distract you from this overlooked gem. The all-butter pound cake is rich, moist, and utterly indulgent in the best possible way.
11. Kirkland Signature Chocolate Cake Filled With Chocolate Mousse – $17.99
Forget the latest viral cheesecakes or elaborately decorated party cakes for a moment. This unadorned, 10-inch round hidden gem, with its perfect chocolate cake and mousse combination, is everything you need and more. No fancy frosting flowers or caramel crust required!
12. Kirkland Signature Sugar Cookies With Sprinkles – $9.99
Tucked away behind tubs of chocolate chip mini cookies and containers of croissants, you might find a special springtime surprise: these sweet, buttery sugar cookies with sprinkles. Their soft, almost spongy texture and delightful flavor are worth savoring.
The Bottom Line
From seasonal decorated tuxedo cakes to irresistible chocolate chunk cookies, you don’t need a special occasion to treat yourself to these delicious Costco bakery finds. And the savings don’t stop there! Pair your favorite desserts with other Kirkland Signature bargains, like their vanilla ice cream or heavy whipped cream.
Read More About This Story:
- 12 Costco Bakery Hidden Gems That Most Shoppers Miss (financebuzz.com)