CLEVELAND, Ohio — Creamy or crunchy? Sweet or salty? Peanut butter fans know there’s nothing casual about a peanut butter craving — and National Peanut Butter Day (Jan. 24) felt like the perfect excuse to lean into it.
So we went a little nuts.
To celebrate, the Best of Cleveland team cracked open 15 different peanut butter sandwich cookies found on local grocery store shelves and put them head-to-head. We were looking for bold peanut butter flavor (in both the cookie and the filling), a satisfying texture and whether the cookies actually delivered on the promises splashed across the package…