Additional Coverage:
- 9 Vintage Cookie Jars That Are Worth a Small Fortune Today (financebuzz.com)
Dust Off That Old Cookie Jar: It Could Be Worth a Fortune!
Who knew that charming cookie jar sitting in your grandma’s kitchen or tucked away in an attic could be a secret goldmine? These mid-20th-century kitchen staples are now serious collector’s items, and some are fetching surprisingly high prices. If you stumble upon one of these vintage treasures, especially at a yard sale or thrift store, you might be holding a lot more than just a place to store your snickerdoodles.
Whether you’re a seasoned collector, a savvy reseller, or just someone who loves the thrill of uncovering hidden gems, here are some vintage cookie jars that could help you pocket some serious cash:
1. Hull Little Red Riding Hood Cookie Jar
Current Market Value: Up to $799.95
Inspired by the classic fairy tale, this Hull jar depicts a sweet Little Red Riding Hood with her basket. While reproductions exist, an authentic piece is a true find. Complete sets with matching creamers and sugar bowls are even more valuable, but the standalone jar can easily resell for hundreds.
2. Metlox Poppytrail Little Red Riding Hood Cookie Jar
Current Market Value: Up to $500
Another take on the beloved character, this Metlox version features a round-faced, blonde Little Red Riding Hood with intricate details. Part of the popular Poppytrail line that began in 1934, these jars are highly sought after by collectors, with prices typically ranging from $300 to $500.
3. American Bisque MoonMan SpaceShip Cookie Jar
Current Market Value: Up to $699.99
Blast off to big bucks with this rare 1960s jar! Featuring a smiling moon man in a rocket proudly proclaiming “Cookies Out of This World,” this piece is a true collector’s dream, provided it’s not a replica. One is currently listed online for just under $700.
4. American Bisque “Little Audrey” Cookie Jar
Current Market Value: Up to $1,950
Standing a notable 13.5 inches tall, this vibrant 1960s jar showcases Little Audrey holding a treat bag. Considered extremely rare, a well-preserved “Little Audrey” can command nearly $2,000.
5. Regal China Alice in Wonderland Cookie Jar
Current Market Value: Up to $1,000
Step into a wonderland of value with this 1951 Regal China release. Standing 13 inches tall and depicting Alice stretching, this jar is a big hit with Disney collectors. A recent sale saw one go for $1,000, and prices can climb higher based on condition.
6. American Bisque Baby Huey Cookie Jar
Current Market Value: Up to $2,000-$4,000
The larger-than-life cartoon duckling, Baby Huey, is immortalized in this rare American Bisque jar, often seen with charmingly faded yellow and blue hues. While one recently sold for $1,200, dedicated collectors have been known to shell out up to $4,000 for this unique piece.
7. American Bisque Casper the Ghost Cookie Jar
Current Market Value: Up to $399
This early 1960s jar features a friendly Casper enjoying a cookie. Though not as high-priced as some of its counterparts, its limited production and devoted fan base mean it consistently sells for around $400 or more.
8. 1973 Holt Howard Tiger “Friends” Cookie Jar
Current Market Value: Up to $15,999.99
Yes, you read that right! This particular Holt Howard Tiger “Friends” cookie jar from 1973 is a highly coveted, extremely valuable piece in the collector’s market.
9. RRP Co. The Cow Jumped Over the Moon Cookie Jar
Current Market Value: Up to $150-$355
This high-gloss, gold-trimmed ceramic jar from the 1940s brings whimsical nursery rhyme characters to life. It’s one of the more accessible yet still valuable jars on this list.
Be sure to look for the “RRP Co. Roseville Ohio” marking to confirm its authenticity.
The Bottom Line
If you’re lucky enough to unearth one of these vintage cookie jars, take the time to ensure it’s not a reproduction. Carefully examine original markings, check the glaze and color for authenticity, and research similar listings to gauge its true worth. Whether you’re aiming to sell or simply add to your collection, these charming jars could be more than just decorative – they might just be the sweet surprise you need to boost your budget!
Read More About This Story:
- 9 Vintage Cookie Jars That Are Worth a Small Fortune Today (financebuzz.com)