There is a bakery in Ohio that people talk about the way you talk about a favorite family recipe, with that quiet pride and a knowing smile. Pies so good that folks drive out of their way, buy four at a time, and hand them out as holiday gifts.
I am not exaggerating when I say that a single visit to this place can genuinely change the way you think about what a pie is supposed to taste like. The crust is real, the fillings are packed, and the prices make you do a double take.
Ohio has plenty of food worth celebrating, but this spot has something that feels rare, a product so consistently good that it has built a loyal following spanning multiple generations. Keep reading, because I am about to tell you everything you need to know.
The Story Behind Gardner Pie Company
Some bakeries earn their reputation over decades, and Gardner Pie Company is exactly that kind of place. The story goes back generations, with roots in Barberton, Ohio, where the original location sat on Van Buren Street and became a Thanksgiving tradition for many local families…