WESTPORT–If the police felt a sense of déjà vu when they traveled to the Bergen County, N.J., Jail to pick a New York City man accused of stealing from Ulta Beauty in town, it was justified.
Police picked up Jefferson Reyes-Castro, 26, on April 15, almost exactly a year after town police had driven to the same jail to collect him in connection with the same incident. On April 30, 2025, they brought him back from the New Jersey facility on a warrant charging him with the theft from the store at 1365 Post Road East, Westport, police said at the time.
Reyes-Castro was charged in connection with a Feb. 21, 2024, incident when two suspects who had been seen fleeing the store with “various items” they had not paid for…