Sheriff Prummell of Punta Gorda, Florida, updated the public on February 8, 2024, about a double homicide case from January 24, 2024. He held a press conference to share details, thanking the public for their patience. He explained that the limited information previously released was to protect the ongoing investigation.
The Sheriff shared that the case began with a 911 call from a worker who heard gunshots. Deputies found two men, Mario Schiano and Anthony Galeotti, dead inside a house on Trails End Dr. The investigation involved interviews, evidence gathering, and a search of the property, which spans 10 acres.
Detectives pursued many leads, some leading them out of state. As the investigation continued, they found enough evidence to arrest Kelly Schiano, Mario’s wife, and Everett Harper. Both are charged with Conspiracy to Commit Murder. The investigation suggests that the motive was related to drugs and money.
Sheriff Prummell did not comment on the possibility of other suspects, stating that any additional individuals need to be caught. He encouraged anyone with information to contact the CCSO non-emergency number or Crime Stoppers.