2355 Vanderbilt Beach Road, Naples; 239-631-6553 or mysticlobsterrollsnaplesfl.com. Mystic Lobster Roll has 10 different styles of the famous seafood sandwich, from the classics of the Connecticut, served with fresh Maine lobster that is warm and drizzled in butter to the New England Roll with mayo and lemon. The Deep South features fresh lobster, chipotle mayo, candied jalapenos and a spicy jalapeno aioli. The Hawaiian is piled with lobster, mango caviar, shredded coconut and coconut mayo. Other options include the BLT, Bombay, the Italian and King Louis XIII.