Additional Coverage:
- Ex-Marine accused of killing homeless man in chokehold on New York subway train ‘went way too far,’ trial hears (newsbreak.com)
Former Marine on Trial for Choking Subway Passenger
The trial began for Daniel Penny, a former Marine charged with killing a homeless man, Jordan Neely, in a subway chokehold.
Starkly Different Accounts
Prosecutors allege that Penny, while initially trying to protect passengers, continued choking Neely even after he lost consciousness. The defense claims Penny acted courageously and used a non-lethal chokehold, suggesting drugs or a genetic condition contributed to Neely’s death.
Competing Views of Chokehold
Experts disagree on the nature of the chokehold used. The defense argues it was nonlethal, while prosecutors say it was a deadly maneuver.
Public Outcry and Divided Opinions
The incident sparked outrage and a debate over the city’s treatment of vulnerable populations and public safety. Some view it as a case of excessive force, while others see Penny as a hero.
Key Evidence
The trial will focus on bystander video of the incident. The prosecution claims Penny approached Neely quickly, while the defense says he had already been struggling with him for minutes.
Potential Sentence
If convicted, Penny faces up to 15 years in prison. New York City Mayor Eric Adams has prioritized policing and involuntary hospitalization of mentally ill individuals in the subway system.