Additional Coverage:
- 9 Precious Moments Figurines That Are Actually Worth a Small Fortune (financebuzz.com)
Could Your Precious Moments Figurines Be Worth a Fortune?
Those teardrop-eyed Precious Moments figurines, popular since 1978 for their heartwarming biblical messages, could be more than just charming collectibles. Some rare editions are fetching impressive prices, turning sentimental treasures into potential cash windfalls.
With new figurines constantly being released (look out for the August 2025 additions!), the market for older editions remains vibrant. While new figurines typically cost between $35 and $150, certain retired pieces are worth significantly more.
Do you own one of these valuable figurines?
Here are some of the most sought-after Precious Moments treasures:
- Jesus is Born (Market Value: $60): Part of the Original 21 collection from 1978, this figurine depicts a shepherd and angel announcing Jesus’s birth. Look for the catalog number E-2012 to verify its authenticity. While many Original 21 figurines sell for $15-$30, this piece can command between $25 and $60.
- Come Let Us Adore Him (Market Value: $100): Another piece from the faith-based Original 21, this figurine shows a figure adoring a baby in a manger. The original Jonathan and David mark (the pen names of creators Sam Butcher and Bill Biel) on the base signifies its value. Expect to see this piece selling for $75 to $100 in good condition.
- God Loveth a Cheerful Giver (Market Value: $300): This 1978 Original 21 figurine, inspired by artist Sam Butcher’s daughter, depicts a girl with a wheelbarrow full of puppies. Its “retired” status (meaning the mold is broken and no more can be produced) adds to its value.
Look for the Jonathan and David mark for authenticity. This piece can fetch $200 to $300.
- A Wonderful Dream Come True (Market Value: $800): This rare Disney collaboration features Cinderella and plays “A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes.” With only 1,500 pieces made, this 2013 figurine (identifiable by a date sticker and the Disney Showcase emblem) is highly sought after. Even slightly damaged pieces have sold for hundreds of dollars.
- Love One Another (Market Value: $500): Uniquely, this Original 21 figurine remains in production. Depicting a boy and girl on a tree stump, original versions with the Jonathan and David mark or a Sam Butcher signature can be worth $500 or more. Be aware of later editions with marks like the Holy Trinity Triangle (added in 1981).
- Jesus Loves Me (Market Value: $900): This Original 21 figurine, available in both girl (holding a bunny) and boy (holding a teddy bear) versions, has been re-released over the years. While values vary, a signed, limited edition recently sold for $900.
- We Would See Jesus (Market Value: $900): This exclusive figurine, sold only at the Precious Moments Chapel in Carthage, Missouri, features three kings with teddy bears on a camel. Released in 2021, this piece has a limited run of 1,500 and features a “Precious Moments by Enesco” stamp and a unique number on its base. Expect prices between $400 and $900.
- A Hui Hou (Market Value: $375): Part of the 2005 Anniversary Hawaiian Collection, this figurine depicts a hula dancer. Limited edition and bearing the name and date on its base, a signed version can be worth anywhere from $375 to $1,950.
- True Love Conquers All (Market Value: Up to $2,999): Another highly desirable Disney collaboration, this 2021 musical piece had a limited production of just 500. Its rarity drives prices up to $2,999 for collectors seeking to complete their sets.
The Bottom Line:
Condition is key when determining the value of Precious Moments figurines. Yearly production marks help authenticate pieces.
Estate sales, thrift stores, auctions, and even online marketplaces can be great places to find hidden treasures. While these figurines are delightful to collect, knowing their potential value adds another dimension to the joy of owning these sentimental pieces.
Read More About This Story:
- 9 Precious Moments Figurines That Are Actually Worth a Small Fortune (financebuzz.com)