Additional Coverage:
- The 7 Worst Italian Chain Restaurants in America (cheapism.com)
A Taste Test Gone Wrong: Unmasking America’s Most Disappointing Italian Chains
There’s a special place in the American culinary heart for Italian comfort food. Whether it’s a heaping bowl of spaghetti and meatballs or a cheesy slice of chicken parmesan, these dishes often evoke warmth and nostalgia.
Fast-casual Italian chains promise to deliver this experience whenever the craving strikes. However, as many diners can attest, not all Italian eateries are created equal.
Some, it seems, have garnered a reputation for falling short, leaving customers with more questions than satisfied cravings.
We’ve taken a look at some of the chain restaurants that frequently land on the “avoid at all costs” list, according to diners across the country.
Fazoli’s
For many, the name Fazoli’s conjures images of a bygone era. It’s a chain often remembered from a distant past, with many questioning if it even still exists.
But beyond the lingering question of its solvency, there’s another, more immediate memory: those famously greasy garlic breadsticks. Drenched in oil, they were once the subject of rumors about being deep-fried.
While perhaps a hit with a younger crowd, the appeal of such a heavy-handed approach seems to wane with age, leaving little else to draw mature palates back.
Bravo! Italian Kitchen
Bravo! Italian Kitchen often finds itself in a precarious position, frequently described as “not great, but better than Olive Garden.”
This rather low bar, however, barely seems to be cleared, with a menu that often mirrors its more famous competitor in its lack of excitement. When diners suggest you might find better pasta at a non-Italian chain like Cheesecake Factory, it speaks volumes.
And that exclamation point in the name? Perhaps a little too enthusiastic for the culinary experience delivered.
Sbarro
The quintessential mall food court staple, Sbarro, has become the subject of countless jokes. As shopping malls have faded from prominence, so too has Sbarro, transforming into a restaurant of last resort found primarily in airports, bus stations, and highway rest stops. The pizza, often sitting under heat lamps for an indeterminate amount of time, is widely known for its dryness, leading many to declare it among the worst pizza experiences available, even compared to other budget delivery options.
The Old Spaghetti Factory
Many fondly recall childhood visits to The Old Spaghetti Factory, captivated by the novelty of dining next to a train car. Yet, for most, the magic of the atmosphere eventually gives way to a realization about the food itself. Former employees have corroborated that the cuisine often resembled cafeteria fare, with one recalling that orders for pre-cooked noodles and ladled sauce were often timed to be plated just minutes before a guest finished their salad, highlighting a focus on efficiency over culinary craft.
Olive Garden
No list of questionable Italian chains would be complete without Olive Garden. The chain’s reputation has been a topic of much discussion, including a much-publicized revelation in 2014 by an activist hedge fund claiming the restaurant doesn’t salt its pasta water to preserve its pots.
Diners frequently note the pasta is consistently overcooked. When an Italian restaurant’s most celebrated offerings are its soup, salad, and breadsticks—rather than its pasta dishes—it signals a fundamental misstep.
While some recall a better era in the 1990s, the introduction of peculiar pasta names like “pastachetti” seemed to mark a turning point from which there was no return.
Johnny Carino’s
Johnny Carino’s has seen a significant decline, shrinking from over 150 locations to roughly 40 today, a clear indicator of its struggles. Customers often find the offerings overpriced for the quality, and the menu features some rather unusual choices, such as “Italian nachos.” Regular complaints include poor customer service, tough chicken parmesan with an unyielding crust, poorly prepared steaks, and sauces that taste watered down.
Romano’s Macaroni Grill
Once a more prominent chain, Romano’s Macaroni Grill declared bankruptcy in 2017 and has yet to fully recover, with only 21 locations remaining, two of which are notably situated in busy airports like Orlando and O’Hare. Diners consistently point to overpriced pasta and a noticeable decline in quality over the years. Many who remember its earlier days lament its fall from grace, comparing its trajectory to that of other once-popular, now struggling, casual dining establishments.
As these chains demonstrate, the allure of Italian comfort food can sometimes lead to disappointment when the execution falls short. Perhaps the best Italian meal, after all, is the one made with care, whether in a small, local trattoria or in your own kitchen.
Read More About This Story:
- The 7 Worst Italian Chain Restaurants in America (cheapism.com)