Unexpected Male Stars We’re Crushing On Now

Additional Coverage:

Move Over, Hollywood Hunks! Our Hearts Beat for These Unconventional Crushes

Tired of the usual suspects like Johnny Depp and Ryan Gosling dominating the “most crushable” lists? So are we!

While we still appreciate a classic heartthrob, it’s time to shine a spotlight on some truly unexpected male celebrities who are stealing hearts left and right. Get ready to do a double-take, because these 15 unconventional crushes make perfect sense.


1. Adam Sandler

Forget the grown-up comedies, we’re talking ’90s Sandler! Think baggy jeans, work boots, and that signature backward baseball cap.

Pure magic. And honestly, he’s still got it at 59, thanks to a little help from some distinguished facial hair.

2. Steve Carell

What kind of GQ-level sorcery was performed on Steve Carell? The salt-and-pepper hair, the sophisticated glasses, the beard – it’s all working! The “40-Year-Old Virgin” days are officially ancient history.

3. Jack Black

Yes, he’s hilarious, but it’s not just the humor that’s captivating. It’s his genuine authenticity and the sheer comfort he exudes in his own skin that truly makes him attractive.

4. Benny Blanco

Selena Gomez, we get it now. Every TikTok video and interview reveals more of the undeniable charm and attraction.

5. Steve Buscemi

Beyond his iconic role in “Airheads,” those piercing blue eyes have a way of seeping into your soul. Especially when paired with a beard, Buscemi’s gaze is mesmerizing.

6. Nick Offerman

No notes needed. Just… Nick Offerman.

7. Kevin James

Bald, bearded, a great smile, and incredibly funny? That’s the winning combo that makes Kevin James undeniably swoon-worthy.

8. Jeff Goldblum

Whether he’s young or old, we’re pretty sure we’re in love with every single iteration of Jeff Goldblum.

9. Bill Hader

There’s something about Bill Hader’s mischievous grin that just hits different.

10. Jason Bateman

It’s his rapid-fire delivery, the way he articulates words without seeming to take a breath – his entire speaking style is a definite “yes.”

11. Seth Rogen

This man has certainly come a long way from his “Knocked Up” days, and we’re here for the transformation.

12. Adrien Brody

That scruff? Absolutely does it for us.

13. Sam Rockwell

Were we supposed to have a crush on the bad guy in “Charlie’s Angels”? Probably not, but we absolutely did.

14. Andy Samberg

Andy Samberg has consistently delivered the perfect dose of quirky charm throughout his career.

15. Walton Goggins

From Venus in “Sons of Anarchy” to Boyd Crowder in “Justified,” we’ve seen him evolve, and we’re thrilled with where he’s landed.


Still looking for more celebrity content?

  • These 17 Leading Men Were the Ultimate Old-School Heartthrobs – Travel back in time to the men who made an entire generation swoon.
  • 20 Candid Photos of Marilyn Monroe Before Hollywood Transformed Her – Discover the real Marilyn before she became a global icon.
  • 13 Actresses Everyone Was Obsessed With in the ’80s – Revisit the beloved actresses of the ’80s, from Molly Ringwald to Lisa Bonet.

Read More About This Story:

TRENDING NOW

LATEST LOCAL NEWS