Experts Give Their Grades for the U.S. Economy This Year

Additional Coverage:

U.S. Economy in 2025: A Mixed Bag of Resilience and Lingering Headwinds

The U.S. economy has navigated a turbulent 2025, defying some early predictions of recession and runaway inflation, yet still leaving many Americans feeling the pinch. While experts laud the economy’s “resilience” in the face of challenges like higher tariffs and a hiring slowdown, the reality on Main Street often paints a different picture.

Defying the Odds (Mostly)

Economists point to a surprising durability in 2025, with economic growth hitting its fastest pace in two years and the stock market reaching new highs. Inflation, while persistent, has risen less dramatically than some initially feared. Michael Pearce, chief U.S. economist at Oxford Economics, described it as “another year of resilience,” with the economy maintaining a “pretty steady pace.”

However, this resilience doesn’t translate to a stellar report card. Pearce, along with other experts, graded the economy in the B to B- range as the year concludes. This assessment stands in stark contrast to the sentiment of most Americans, with three-quarters of those surveyed by CBS News assigning the economy a C, D, or F.

The Great Disconnect: Wall Street vs. Main Street

This divergence largely stems from differing perspectives. Economists tend to focus on macroeconomic indicators like GDP, inflation rates, and unemployment figures. Consumers, on the other hand, often base their economic outlook on “pocketbook issues” – the rising cost of groceries, healthcare premiums, and the struggle to achieve traditional financial milestones.

The White House, under President Trump, highlighted improvements from the previous year, citing “cooled inflation, private-sector job growth, cheaper essentials like gas, lower taxes, and trillions in investments.” White House spokesman Kush Desai expressed confidence that 2026 would be “even better” as the President’s economic agenda continues to take effect.

A Turbulent Year: Tariffs and Policy Shifts

2025 was marked by significant volatility and uncertainty. President Trump’s sweeping tariffs, announced in April, initially sent shockwaves through the stock market and raised fears of renewed inflation. While the tariffs’ impact on inflation has been more muted than anticipated – partly due to companies absorbing costs and stockpiling goods – they still contributed an estimated 0.5 percentage points to the nation’s inflation rate.

“It’s rare that we’ve seen a president come in and, with a unified Congress, have such immediate impacts on the economy,” Pearce noted, emphasizing the uncertainty generated by these policy shifts.

Other legislative changes, like the “big beautiful bill” act, are expected to have a mixed impact. While some consumers may see larger tax refunds in 2026, the expiration of enhanced tax credits under the Affordable Care Act is projected to significantly increase health insurance premiums for millions.

Meanwhile, a booming artificial intelligence sector fueled a banner year for investors, pushing the stock market to record highs. However, this bullish sentiment has also sparked concerns about a potential AI bubble, questioning whether the massive investment in the technology will ultimately deliver on its promises of increased productivity and profits.

Life on the “K”: A Divided Economic Experience

The economic landscape of 2025 has been described as “K-shaped,” illustrating a growing divide. Higher-income consumers, bolstered by a strong stock market, continue to spend robustly. Conversely, lower- and middle-income Americans are pulling back, grappling with stubbornly high prices and the increasing difficulty of achieving financial security.

Inflation, though it has cooled from its 2022 peak, remains elevated, straining household budgets. Mark Luschini of Janney Montgomery Scott highlighted the struggle many Americans face in covering basic expenses. Chen Zhao of Redfin added that once-ordinary financial goals, like buying a first home or saving for retirement, are becoming increasingly out of reach.

The median age for first-time homebuyers hit a record high of 40 this year, a stark illustration of the affordability crisis. With home values near all-time highs and mortgage rates around 6.3%, younger generations are increasingly priced out of homeownership, delaying what Zhao calls “the American dream.”

Slowing Labor Market and Federal Reserve Action

Another area of concern is the labor market, which has seen a slowdown in hiring throughout 2025. The U.S. unemployment rate climbed to 4.6% in November, its highest in four years, and layoffs jumped 54% from the previous year, reaching levels not seen since 2020.

This cooling job market, partly attributed to economic uncertainty and the increasing adoption of AI, poses challenges for job seekers, particularly young people entering the workforce. To counter these headwinds and encourage business expansion, the Federal Reserve has cut its benchmark interest rate three times since September.

Economists warn that a weaker labor market could ultimately dampen consumer spending, which is a major driver of economic activity. As Greg Daco of EY-Parthenon explained, “A slower labor market leads to slower income growth, which eventually ends up pulling consumer spending lower.”

As 2025 draws to a close, the U.S. economy presents a complex picture of surprising strength in some areas, juxtaposed with persistent challenges and a noticeable divide in how different segments of the population are experiencing its effects.


Read More About This Story:

TRENDING NOW

LATEST LOCAL NEWS