Additional Coverage:
Sweet Steals: Sam’s Club Desserts That Taste Like a Bakery (But Cost Way Less!)
Let’s face it, a fancy bakery treat can put a serious dent in your grocery budget. But what if we told you that Sam’s Club is secretly a treasure trove of delicious desserts that rival the pros, often for a fraction of the price? Get ready to satisfy your sweet tooth without breaking the bank, because we’ve uncovered some seriously impressive alternatives lurking in their fridge and freezer aisles.
From classic cheesecakes to gourmet cupcakes, these treats offer big flavor, great quality, and unbeatable convenience. So, next time that dessert craving hits, bypass the boutique bakeries and head straight to Sam’s Club for these incredible finds.
(Editor’s note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.)
1. Member’s Mark New York Style Cheesecake
Price: $14.78
This 9-inch classic is a fan favorite for a reason! Thick, creamy, and perfectly balanced in sweetness, reviewers often compare it favorably to slices from The Cheesecake Factory – but without the hefty $10 per plate price tag. Its buttery graham cracker crust and smooth filling hold up beautifully when thawed overnight, making it a perfect make-ahead dessert.
2. Sublime Desserts Macarons Assorted Flavors
Price: $14.94
Indulge your sophisticated side with these imported French-style macarons. With 36 pieces per box, they offer boutique bakery quality at an incredible value. Delicate shells give way to smooth, creamy centers in delightful flavors like chocolate fudge, salted caramel, and pink lemonade.
3. Member’s Mark Tuxedo Bar Cake with Chocolate Mousse
Price: $16.94
Prepare for a showstopper! This triple-layer cake is dense, moist, and deeply chocolatey.
It’s garnered comparisons to premium bakery cakes from Whole Foods and even Milk Bar, but without the boutique markup. Layers of rich chocolate cake, dreamy chocolate mousse, and cream cheese frosting create a truly decadent experience.
4. Member’s Mark Key Lime Pie
Price: $9.98
A true hidden gem, this 10-inch refrigerated pie is tangy, smooth, and incredibly refreshing. It holds its own against key lime pie slices found at The Cheesecake Factory and upscale delis, yet costs less than $10 for the entire pie! No thawing needed – just add whipped cream and a sprinkle of lime zest for an instant crowd-pleaser.
5. Member’s Mark Tiramisu Cake
Price: $14.98
Experience a surprisingly authentic taste with this refrigerated tiramisu. Layers of espresso-soaked cake, mascarpone mousse, and cocoa powder come together for a dessert many reviewers say surpasses pre-sliced grocery store options and even rivals restaurant versions. Serve with a side of espresso or dark chocolate shavings for an elevated treat.
6. Member’s Mark Jumbo Gourmet Chocolate Chip and Chunk Cookie Dough
Price: $11.86
Craving warm, fresh-baked cookies without the fuss? This frozen cookie dough delivers bakery-quality results right at home. It bakes up soft in the center with perfectly crispy edges, and here’s a bonus: it’s safe to eat raw!
7. Member’s Mark Cheesecake Minis
Price: $18.27
Perfect for parties or a personal indulgence, this freezer sampler offers 1-inch bite-sized portions in three delicious flavors: New York Style, Caramel Chocolate Chip, and Strawberry Swirl. Sam’s Club shopper Terri H. raves, “Always have these in the freezer for a yummy, delicious bite.
No need for a big slice. Three flavors in box.
Have 1 of each. Perfect!!!”
For the best texture, thaw them overnight in the fridge.
8. Member’s Mark Gourmet Brownie Tray
Price: $20.93
These rich, dense, and deeply chocolatey brownie bites taste more homemade than anything you’d typically find at a grocery store bakery. They’re conveniently snackable right out of the fridge.
Shopper Jane R. declared them “Absolutely Delicious. They were soft, flavorful, and a hit.
Will buy again for any event we go to.”
9. Member’s Mark 10″ Tres Leches Style Cake with Strawberry Filling
Price: $18.98
This moist, milky cake is a delightful balance of flavors, layered with sweet strawberry filling and topped with whipped cream. It’s perfect for celebrations or as a special treat, incredibly easy to serve straight from the fridge, and at 10 inches, ideal for feeding a crowd.
10. Member’s Mark Sweet Fruit Topped Chantilly Cream Bar Cake
Price: $17.98
Baked fresh in-store daily, this light and airy cake is a visual and culinary delight. Adorned with a variety of fresh fruits and sumptuous Chantilly cream, it’s perfect for all your summer gatherings. This Sam’s Club version is nearly half the price by weight of Walmart’s similar offering!
11. Member’s Mark Cherry Lattice Pie
Price: $9.98
With a flaky lattice crust and a sweet-tart cherry filling, this 10-inch pie evokes the comforting taste of homemade. Take it out of the fridge, warm it slightly, and serve with vanilla ice cream for a delightful treat, even during summer.
12. Member’s Mark Gourmet Cupcakes
Price: $10.98
This 8-pack of gourmet cupcakes offers something for everyone with lemon, strawberry, chocolate, and cookies ‘n creme flavors, each featuring delightful toppings. Perfect for birthdays, celebrations, or an indulgent treat, Sam’s Club’s gourmet cupcakes are a steal compared to Walmart’s similar version.
13. SUMM!
Strawberry Apple Pie Dessert Rolls with Icing
Price: $8.87
These fridge-friendly dessert rolls are a handheld pastry dream, taking everything you love about warm fruit pie and rolling it up. With a flaky exterior and a generous strawberry-apple filling, they’re surprisingly satisfying – like a delicious cross between a bakery Danish and a fruit cobbler. Reviewer ejb156 even compared them to “rolled up toaster strudels.”
14. Member’s Mark Honeycrisp Apple Lattice Pie
Price: $10.98
This generous 12-inch pie boasts all the charm of a made-from-scratch bakery classic. Pre-baked and ready to heat, it’s perfect for a last-minute dessert that tastes anything but store-bought. Serve warm with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream or a drizzle of caramel sauce to turn it into a crowd-pleaser for any family gathering.
15. Member’s Mark Pumpkin Spice Cake Balls
Price: $18.98
These vibrant, moist pumpkin-spice cake bites are available in two charming fall designs. Each bite delivers a punchy flavor you’d expect from a boutique bakery, with several reviewers comparing them favorably to seasonal Crumbl cookie flavors. Ready to serve straight from the fridge, they’re perfect for any gathering or simply treating yourself.
The Sweet Takeaway
Sam’s Club’s fridge and freezer dessert sections are packed with hidden gems that offer bakery-quality taste at a fraction of the price. Stocking up on these treats not only saves you time but also helps you save money on groceries, especially when entertaining. Go ahead, indulge a little – your wallet (and your taste buds) will thank you!