Cassette Tapes in Your Attic Could Be Worth Thousands

Additional Coverage:

13 Cassette Tapes That Are Worth a Small Fortune (financebuzz.com)

Dust Off Those Old Cassettes! Your Attic Could Be Hiding a Fortune

In these days of rising prices, it feels like everyone’s looking for a little extra pocket change. And what better way to boost your bank account than by turning a hobby into a side hustle? Forget elaborate schemes – sometimes, the treasures you seek are gathering dust right under your nose.

We’re talking about cassette tapes, folks! That’s right, those plastic rectangles of musical nostalgia could be worth a surprising amount of cash.

Whether you’ve got a forgotten collection in the attic or a keen eye for hidden gems at the thrift store, it’s time to dig in. We’ve rounded up 13 cassette tapes that could fetch you a pretty penny.

1. Prince – The Black Album

Much like many of Prince’s original creations, “The Black Album” never saw an official public release. Originally slated for 1987, Prince famously pulled the plug due to a spiritual awakening.

However, a small, undisclosed number of copies did leak out, making these original cassettes incredibly valuable – some have sold for nearly $5,000. In fact, a 1987 promo cassette once raked in a staggering $8,750 in 2017!

2. The Beastie Boys – Licensed to Ill (First Edition)

Released to widespread acclaim in 1986, the first edition of “Licensed to Ill” is now a rare find. If you’re lucky enough to have a factory-sealed copy, you could be looking at up to $1,500. Even brand-new copies can command around $450, while used versions, depending on their condition, might bring in $25 to $50.

3. Deftones – Deftones

Talk about limited edition! Deftones only produced 15 cassette copies of their initial self-titled release.

These unique tapes featured their first manager’s phone number on the jacket and had the same four songs on both sides. In 2024, one of these 1992 releases sold for an impressive $5,000.

4. Pearl Jam – Ten

Pearl Jam’s iconic 1991 studio album, featuring classics like “Porch” and “Even Flow,” is a fan favorite. While a sealed, first-pressing cassette has sold for as much as $4,000, copies in new condition typically go for $400 to $700. Currently, the priciest option on eBay is listed at $663.80.

5. Nas – Illmatic

Nas’s “Illmatic,” adorned with a childhood photo of the artist, is widely celebrated as one of hip-hop’s most influential albums. A sealed cassette could net you up to $900, with the most recent high sale hitting just over $305. Even used copies often fetch around $100.

6. Prince – The Versace Experience – Prelude 2 Gold

In 1995, this ultra-rare promotional cassette by Prince was exclusively handed out at Versace’s Paris Fashion Week show. Though it had no initial retail value, one copy recently sold for an astounding $4,011!

7. Alvvays – Adult Diversion

Here’s a newer release that’s packing serious value: Alvvays’ 2013 single cassette for “Adult Diversion.” This was an independent release before they signed with Polyvinyl, meaning very few copies were produced. The most expensive one sold for $3,423.36.

8. Nirvana – Nevermind

Nirvana unleashed the instant cult classic “Nevermind” in 1991, forever cementing its place in music history. Sealed cassette copies of this legendary album have sold for up to $1,500 on eBay, and even used versions can bring in a respectable sum.

9. Eminem – Infinite

While a signed, sealed vinyl of Eminem’s “Infinite” could buy you a new SUV, an original cassette could also make you a pretty penny. A set featuring a collector’s re-issue (copy #9 of 100) and a 2018 Slim Shady EP cassette is currently listed online for $2,000.

10. Phish – Phish

Phish fans, rejoice! The band’s 1987 self-titled cassette is worth hundreds of dollars depending on its condition. A copy in very good condition sold for $1,200 in 2024.

11. Michael Jackson – Man in the Mirror

As the King of Pop, any Michael Jackson cassette can garner a return, especially rarities. The original demo tape of his hit single “Man in the Mirror” is highly coveted by collectors and is estimated to be worth between $30,000 and $50,000! You might never see one, but it’s good to dream!

12. Xero – Xero

Before they were Linkin Park, they were Xero, and their self-released, self-titled full-length demo from years ago is now worth thousands. Its rarity and the fact that the band no longer exists under that name or original lineup have seen it sell for as much as $4,500.

13. David Bowie – The Man Who Sold The World

David Bowie’s iconic 1970 album, “The Man Who Sold The World,” features an elevated, jewel-toned photograph on its cover. This album is a rare find, and collectors are always on the lookout. The U.K. version of this release is known to go for around $200 in decent condition.

The Bottom Line: Turn Your Nostalgia into Cash

So, what are you waiting for? You could be making some extra cash simply by sifting through your old albums and cassettes to unearth those hidden gems.

If you’re looking to make a hobby out of it, start scouting your local thrift shops, secondhand stores, and estate sales for valuable tapes. Happy hunting!