Indiana might be famous for its cornfields and racing heritage, but locals know it’s also home to some incredible steakhouses. From historic establishments that have served generations of Hoosiers to modern chophouses pushing culinary boundaries, the state boasts serious beef credentials. These ten restaurants have earned legendary status among Indiana steak lovers, each offering something special that keeps locals coming back for more.
1. St. Elmo Steak House — Indianapolis
Stepping into St. Elmo feels like entering a time capsule of Indianapolis history. Since 1902, this downtown landmark has been serving up perfectly aged Black Angus steaks with unwavering consistency.
Famous patrons from presidents to celebrities have dined beneath the dark wood and brass fixtures, but locals know the real initiation is surviving the legendary shrimp cocktail—a sinus-clearing experience that’s become an Indiana rite of passage.
The dry-aged bone-in ribeye remains the star attraction, though regulars often praise the filet mignon as being butter-soft. Reservations are essential, especially during conventions or Colts games.
2. Janko’s Little Zagreb — Bloomington
Hidden near Indiana University’s campus, Little Zagreb has been Bloomington’s worst-kept secret since 1973. The modest exterior belies what awaits inside—massive, char-seared steaks that have developed a cult following among students, professors, and visiting celebrities alike…